Why Are Crumbl Cookies So High in Calories?

If you’ve ever bitten into a Crumbl Cookie, you know just how soft, sweet, and satisfying it can be. But after a few bites, you may start to wonder — why are Crumbl Cookies so high in calories? The answer lies in their size, ingredients, and how they’re made.

In this blog, we’ll break it down in a simple way. We’ll talk about what goes into these cookies, how many calories they really have, and what that means for your diet. If you’re watching your health, trying to lose weight, or just curious about your food, this post is for you.

What Is a Crumbl Cookie?

Crumbl Cookies is a popular bakery chain known for its gourmet, oversized cookies. Each week, the company rotates its cookie menu, offering new flavors like Churro, Peanut Butter Cup, Cookies & Cream, and more.

Their cookies are famous for being:

• Thick and gooey
• Rich in flavor
• Big enough to share (but most don’t!)

But with that comes a very high calorie count—some Crumbl cookies have over 600 calories per cookie!

How Many Calories Are in a Crumbl Cookie?

Average Calorie Range

A single Crumbl Cookie can contain between 550 to 850 calories, depending on the flavor. Here’s a look at a few examples:

That’s more than what you’d get in a Big Mac or a full meal at many fast food restaurants.

Why Are Crumbl Cookies So High in Calories?

Let’s explore what makes these cookies so calorie-packed.

1. Large Portion Sizes

Most cookies you find at the store are around 2 inches wide and weigh about 1 ounce. A Crumbl cookie? It’s usually 4-5 inches wide and weighs up to 5.5 ounces. That’s 5 times bigger than a regular cookie!

Larger size = more ingredients = more calories.

2. High Sugar Content

Sugar is one of the top ingredients in Crumbl Cookies. It makes them sweet and chewy, but also adds lots of calories.

• 1 gram of sugar = 4 calories
• A Crumbl cookie can contain 50–90 grams of sugar

That’s more than double the daily limit recommended by the American Heart Association for most adults.

3. Butter and Fats

Butter gives Crumbl cookies their rich, soft texture, but it’s also loaded with fat and calories.

• 1 tablespoon of butter = 100 calories
• Crumbl uses a lot of butter, and sometimes oils and cream cheese too

All that fat contributes to a higher calorie count, especially when paired with sugary frostings.

4. Toppings and Fillings

Crumbl doesn’t just make plain cookies. Most are topped or filled with:

• Frosting
• Caramel
• Candy pieces
• Peanut butter
• Chocolate drizzle

These extras add hundreds of calories. One cookie can have more than 25 grams of fat and over 60 grams of sugar—which is nearly a full dessert in itself.

5. Low Nutrient Density

Crumbl cookies are high in calories but low in nutrients. That means:

• They give you a lot of energy (calories)
• But not a lot of vitamins, fiber, or minerals

This makes them a “calorie-dense food” — something that’s best eaten in moderation.

Is It Okay to Eat Crumbl Cookies?

Yes, you can eat Crumbl Cookies—just not every day.

When It’s Okay:

• Special occasions (birthdays, holidays)
• Once in a while treat
• Shared with friends or family

Tips to Enjoy Without Overdoing It:

• Cut the cookie in half or quarters
• Share with others
• Balance it out with healthy meals for the day
• Drink water instead of soda or juice with it

Are There Healthier Crumbl Options?

Crumbl doesn’t market itself as a health food brand, but some flavors are slightly lower in calories. These include:

• Sugar Cookie (without frosting)
• Oatmeal Raisin (lighter on toppings)

However, even these options still land between 500–600 calories each. So while you might choose the “healthier” option, it’s still a treat.

Can You Burn Off a Crumbl Cookie?

Yes—but it takes effort.

Let’s say you eat one 700-calorie Crumbl cookie. Here’s what you’d need to do to burn it off (based on a 155-pound person):

As you can see, it takes a lot of physical activity to burn off just one cookie.

Hidden Calories in Drinks and Sides

Often, people enjoy their Crumbl Cookies with milk, coffee, or ice cream. These extras can add another 150–300 calories to your snack.

• 8 oz whole milk: 150 calories
• Sweetened coffee drink: 200–250 calories
• Scoop of ice cream: 250 calories

Combined, you could easily consume 1,000+ calories in just one sitting.

Better Alternatives for Sweet Cravings

If you love sweets but want to eat fewer calories, try these instead:

DIY Cookie at Home

Make your own cookies using:

• Whole wheat flour
• Less sugar
• Greek yogurt or applesauce instead of butter

Fruit-Based Desserts

Try:

• Banana slices with peanut butter
• Baked apples with cinnamon
• Greek yogurt with honey and berries

These give you sweetness, fewer calories, and more nutrition.

Final Thoughts

So, why are Crumbl Cookies so high in calories?

It’s because of their:

• Large size
• Sugar-heavy recipes
• High-fat content
• Loaded toppings and fillings

They taste amazing, but one cookie can equal an entire meal’s worth of calories.

Enjoying them once in a while is totally fine—just be mindful of how often and how much. Think of Crumbl cookies as a luxury dessert, not a daily snack.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) on Why Are Crumbl Cookies So High in Calories?

1. Are Crumbl Cookies unhealthy?

Crumbl cookies are high in sugar, fat, and calories. They’re not ideal for everyday snacking but okay in moderation as a treat.

2. How many calories are in half a Crumbl Cookie?

Half a cookie has around 275–400 calories, depending on the flavor and toppings.

3. Can I eat a Crumbl Cookie while on a diet?

Yes, but only occasionally. Try sharing it or saving half for later to keep your calorie intake in check.

4. Do Crumbl Cookies have nutritional information?

Yes. Crumbl provides nutrition facts on its website and app, including calories, fat, carbs, and sugar per cookie.

5. What’s the healthiest Crumbl Cookie flavor?

The least calorie-heavy options are usually plain sugar cookies or oatmeal-based ones, but even these are still quite high in calories.